By Jason Boice, REALTOR®, eXp Realty — Published on January 23, 2026

 Prefer video? Watch the full breakdown here:
 Property Taxes in Tolland vs Surrounding Towns (Mill Rates vs Reality)

Tolland Property Taxes at a Glance

• Tolland’s current mill rate is 27.19, one of the lowest in the region

• Colchester is 29.92, Glastonbury 31.93, Hebron 34.50, Marlborough 37.74, and East Hampton 39.71

• Mill rate alone doesn’t determine taxes — assessed value matters just as much

• Tolland’s real advantage is consistency and fewer tax surprises over time

Why Tolland Is Known for Stable Property Taxes

If you’re researching property taxes in Tolland, Connecticut, you’ve probably noticed something right away:

Tolland doesn’t always get labeled as the cheapest town — but it consistently comes up as one of the most predictable.

That distinction matters more than most buyers realize.

Tolland’s tax stability isn’t accidental. It’s driven by:

• A larger and more diversified grand list

• Fewer extreme swings in home values

• More uniform neighborhoods

• No lake-driven assessment spikes

That combination creates steadier tax bills year over year, which is especially appealing to buyers planning to stay put.

Property Taxes 101: Mill Rate Is Only Half the Story

Connecticut property taxes are calculated using a simple formula:

Mill Rate × Assessed Value

Most people focus only on the mill rate because it’s easy to Google. But assessed value — shaped by revaluation cycles, neighborhood patterns, and property type — plays an equally important role.

This is where towns start to behave very differently.

Current Mill Rate Comparison (Town Website Data)

Here are the current adopted mill rates buyers usually see when checking town tax collector pages:

• Tolland: 27.19 mills

• Colchester: 29.92 mills

• Glastonbury: 31.93 mills

• Hebron: 34.50 mills

• Marlborough: 37.74 mills

• East Hampton: 39.71 mills

On paper, Tolland clearly looks less expensive.

But the real advantage shows up when you factor in assessed values and volatility.

Why Tolland Taxes Are More Predictable

Compared to nearby towns, Tolland typically experiences:

• Fewer dramatic reassessment swings

• Less neighborhood-to-neighborhood variance

• More consistent valuation trends

This contrasts sharply with towns like East Hampton, where lake proximity can dramatically affect assessments, or Marlborough, where a smaller tax base puts more pressure on homeowners.

Tolland doesn’t win on extremes — it wins on stability.

How Tolland Compares to Nearby Towns

Buyers often cross-shop Tolland with surrounding towns. Here’s how it typically stacks up:

• East Hampton: Highest variability due to lake-driven assessed values

• Marlborough: Higher overall taxes, smaller tax base

• Hebron: Middle ground with more rural variability

• Colchester: Competitive but neighborhood-dependent

• Glastonbury: Higher overall taxes due to higher assessed values

Tolland stands out because it trades highs and lows for steadiness.

Who Tolland Makes Financial Sense For

Tolland Is a Good Fit If:

• You want predictable ownership costs

• You’re budgeting carefully month-to-month

• You prefer suburban-style neighborhoods

• You plan to stay medium to long term

Tolland May Not Be Ideal If:

• You’re chasing the absolute lowest taxes at any cost

• You want lakefront property or large rural acreage

• You expect tax volatility to work in your favor

The Biggest Mistake Buyers Make

The most common mistake buyers make is asking:

“Which town has the lowest mill rate?”

The better question is:

“Which town gives me predictable taxes over time on this specific property?”

That’s where Tolland often shines.

Final Thoughts

Tolland isn’t flashy from a property-tax perspective — and that’s exactly why many buyers choose it.

 Watch the full video breakdown here:
 Property Taxes in Tolland vs Surrounding Towns (Mill Rates vs Reality)

If you’re comparing Tolland to Colchester, East Hampton, Marlborough, Hebron, or Glastonbury and want help walking through real tax numbers on specific homes, that kind of planning is exactly what I help buyers with.

Frequently Asked Questions About Property Taxes in Tolland, CT

Are property taxes low in Tolland, Connecticut?
Tolland has one of the lower mill rates in the region at 27.19, but its biggest advantage is predictability rather than simply being the lowest.

Why are Tolland property taxes more predictable?
Tolland has a larger, more diversified grand list and fewer extreme assessed-value swings than nearby towns.

Is Tolland cheaper than Colchester for property taxes?
In many cases, yes. Tolland’s mill rate is lower (27.19 vs 29.92), and similar homes often carry lower or comparable tax bills.

How does Tolland compare to East Hampton for taxes?
East Hampton has much higher variability due to lake-driven assessed values. Tolland is far more consistent.

Is mill rate enough to compare property taxes?
No. Property taxes are calculated using mill rate × assessed value. Looking at only one leads to misleading conclusions.

About the Author

Jason Boice is a REALTOR® with eXp Realty serving Hebron, Andover, Marlborough, Colchester, East Hampton, Tolland, and surrounding Connecticut towns. He helps homeowners buy and sell with clear pricing strategies, professional marketing, and a low-stress process built around real data — not guesswork.

Thinking about buying or selling?
Get a no-pressure strategy consultation so you understand your options before making a decision.
Call or text me at 860-452-3153.