By Jason Boice, REALTOR®, eXp Realty — Published on February 19, 2026

East Hampton, Connecticut is one of the most visually appealing towns in central Connecticut.

It has a true town center. It has local restaurants. And it has Lake Pocotopaug — which draws a lot of attention from buyers looking for charm and lifestyle.

For the right person, East Hampton can be an incredible long-term fit.

But it is not for everyone.

Before you fall in love with lake photos or a charming colonial near the center of town, it’s important to understand what daily life in East Hampton actually looks like.

 Watch the full video here:
 (Insert YouTube link: Who Should NOT Move to East Hampton, CT)

TL;DR — East Hampton Is NOT for You If…

• You want major retail, nightlife, or big-city energy

• You expect luxury lake living without trade-offs

• You need a short, perfectly predictable commute

• Being very close to a full-service hospital is critical

• You’re choosing strictly based on top-10 school rankings

• You want low-maintenance, plug-and-play living

East Hampton works best for people who value charm, character, and lifestyle over convenience and scale.

1. You Want Major Amenities and Big Suburban Energy

East Hampton has a real town center with local restaurants, small shops, and community events.

But it does not have:

• Large retail districts

• Big-box shopping clusters

• A major nightlife scene

• High-density suburban development

East Hampton has charm — not scale.

If you’re looking for a West Hartford–style restaurant scene or major shopping areas minutes from your house, East Hampton will likely feel small.

2. You’re Only Moving for the Lake

Lake Pocotopaug is one of East Hampton’s biggest draws.

But buyers often misunderstand what “lake living” actually means.

Important realities:

• Not all homes have lake access

• Not all lake neighborhoods feel the same

• Lakefront properties come with higher costs and maintenance

• Summer traffic and seasonal activity increase significantly

Living near a lake and living on a lake are two very different experiences.

If your expectations are based purely on photos, you need clarity before committing.

3. You Need a Short, Predictable Commute

East Hampton feels centrally located, but commute times add up.

Typical drive times (depending on traffic and weather):

• Hartford: roughly 30–40 minutes

• UConn (Storrs): roughly 40–45 minutes

• The shoreline: roughly 35–50 minutes

Winter weather can stretch those numbers quickly.

If your lifestyle depends on short, highly predictable commutes year-round, East Hampton may feel farther than expected.

4. You Need a Full-Service Hospital in Town

East Hampton does not have a full-service hospital within town limits.

Most residents travel 20–40 minutes for inpatient care, surgery, or specialty services.

For many buyers, that’s completely reasonable.

For others — particularly those with ongoing medical needs — proximity to hospital care can be a deciding factor.

5. You’re Choosing Strictly Based on School Rankings

East Hampton has a respected school system that serves many families well.

However, it is not consistently ranked among the top 10 districts statewide.

If your decision is based purely on chasing the highest statewide rankings, East Hampton may not be your first choice — even though many families are very satisfied with the schools.

6. You Want Low-Maintenance Living

Many homes in East Hampton feature:

• Septic systems

• Oil or propane heating

• Sloped or wooded lots

• Older lake cottages converted to year-round homes

Character often comes with upkeep.

If you prefer newer subdivisions with minimal maintenance responsibilities, East Hampton may feel like more work than expected.

Who East Hampton IS Great For

East Hampton is an excellent fit for people who:

• Love water and outdoor recreation

• Appreciate small-town charm

• Are comfortable driving for larger amenities

• Want more personality than a typical subdivision town

• Value lifestyle over convenience

For the right buyer, East Hampton delivers long-term satisfaction.

Frequently Asked Questions About Living in East Hampton, CT

Is East Hampton, CT a good place to live?
Yes — for the right buyer. East Hampton is ideal for those who value lake access, small-town charm, and outdoor recreation. It is less ideal for buyers seeking major retail, nightlife, or highly ranked school districts as their only priority.

Is Lake Pocotopaug public?
Lake Pocotopaug includes both public and private access areas. Not all properties include lake rights, and lakefront homes come with additional considerations.

How far is East Hampton from Hartford?
East Hampton is approximately 30–40 minutes from Hartford under normal driving conditions, with longer times during traffic or winter weather.

Does East Hampton have a hospital?
There is no full-service hospital in East Hampton. Residents typically travel 20–40 minutes for hospital care.

Are East Hampton schools highly ranked?
The schools are well-regarded locally but are not consistently ranked among the top districts statewide.

About the Author

Jason Boice is a REALTOR® with eXp Realty serving Hebron, Andover, Marlborough, Colchester, East Hampton, Tolland, and surrounding Connecticut towns. He helps homeowners sell with clear pricing strategies, professional marketing, and a low-stress process built around real data — not guesswork.

Thinking about selling your home in East Hampton?
Get a no-pressure home value and strategy consultation so you understand your options before making a decision. Call or text me at 860-452-3153.